Mortgage basics

Should I refinance? How to read the break-even

The short answer

Refinancing makes sense when what you save outlasts what it costs you, and the break-even point is how you tell. It is the length of time it takes for your savings to pay back the cost of the new loan. If you will stay in the home well past it, it can be worth doing. If you might move sooner, it often is not.

Should I refinance? How to read the break-even
Save it for later · Pin it

What break-even actually means

Every refinance has a cost to do it and a benefit you get from it. The break-even point is how long it takes for the benefit to pay back the cost. If you stay in the home past that point, the refinance came out ahead. If you sell or refinance again before it, you spent more than you saved.

It sounds simple, and it is, but only if you count both sides honestly.

The cost side

A refinance is a new loan, so it comes with its own closing costs: lender fees, an appraisal in many cases, title and escrow, and recording. Some lenders offer a loan with fewer costs up front, but then the trade shows up somewhere else, usually in the rate or the loan balance. Ask for the full Loan Estimate and read the costs page, not just the monthly payment line.

Rolling the costs into the loan is common, and it is not wrong. Just know that you then pay interest on those costs for as long as you have the loan.

The benefit side

The benefit is usually a lower monthly payment, but it can also be a shorter term, a switch away from an adjustable rate, or cash taken out for a project or to pay off other debt. Those are different goals, and the break-even looks different for each one. A lower payment is the easiest to measure: divide what the refinance costs by what it saves you each month.

One thing people miss is the term. If you are several years into your current loan and you start a fresh long term, a lower payment can still mean more total interest over the life of the loan. Lower payment and lower total cost are not always the same thing, so ask to see both.

The questions that change the answer

  • How long will you really stay? If you might get orders, move for work or sell in a few years, a long break-even is a bad bet.
  • Is this the same kind of loan? Moving from one type of loan to another can change your mortgage insurance and what you pay over time. Your lender confirms what applies to you.
  • What are you giving up? If your current loan has terms you like, that is part of the math.
  • Is the number on the page real? Compare the Loan Estimate line by line, including the annual percentage rate, and ask what is and is not included.

How I run it for you

Because I am both your REALTOR® and your mortgage broker, I can run the break-even with you and tell you plainly if waiting, or not refinancing at all, is the better move. I would rather lose a refinance than have you do one that does not pay off. You can start with the calculators on my site, then send me your current loan details and I will walk through it with you.

Questions people also ask

What is a refinance break-even point?

It is how long it takes for what you save with the new loan to pay back what the refinance costs. If you stay in the home past that point, the refinance came out ahead. If you sell or refinance again before it, you spent more than you saved.

What counts as a cost of refinancing?

A refinance is a new loan, so it has its own closing costs: lender fees, an appraisal in many cases, title and escrow, and recording. Rolling the costs into the loan is common, but then you pay interest on them for as long as you have the loan.

Does a lower monthly payment always mean a better refinance?

No. If you are several years into your loan and start a fresh long term, a lower payment can still mean more total interest over the life of the loan. Ask to see both the monthly payment and the total cost.

Julie Herrmann
Written byJulie Herrmann

REALTOR® with Kelly Right Real Estate, LLC (WA #25027756) and mortgage broker with Edge Home Finance (NMLS #1563583). I help people buy, sell and finance homes in Spokane, Cheney, the West Plains and around Fairchild, so the house and the payment get talked about in the same conversation.

More about me
Next step

Want to see it in person?

Tell me what you are looking for and I will line up homes, run the payment on each one and answer the questions a listing can’t.